"If we don't compromise, that reef won't be available for recreation for another five to 10 years."
The monthly salvage bill following the Rena's grounding last October had run to $13.2 million and as of last month The Swedish Club had spent more than $200 million.
"It would be good to have the thing gone regardless of costs, but I won't live long enough to dive or fish at the reef ever again if it goes that way," Mr Wills said.
Labour has, meanwhile, hit out at the Government for having failed to introduce legislation protecting taxpayers from the costs of another environmental disaster.
A document from Transport Minister Gerry Brownlee, obtained under the Official Information Act, revealed the Rena's eventual total cost to the Government could be around $50 million.