She told the court she didn’t get angry at him without provocation.
“I would retaliate to him abusing me.”
Social media was allegedly an ongoing issue for the pair, and the complainant earlier said she “had to delete my social media to prove to him I wasn’t being a ‘ho’.”
When she did have social media, she claimed he would check her follower count “every second day”.
Gray put to the woman that she also didn’t like him being on social media.
The complainant said she didn’t mind him being on it, but began mirroring his behaviour as she thought it was unfair he was able to keep his social media when he said she shouldn’t use hers.
She said he made her remove male followers that weren’t relatives, whereas he wanted to keep his female followers “because they were fans and wanted to appreciate his art”.
During the afternoon session, Gray shared phone records showing one-sided messages from the complainant “bombarding” the man with texts and calls.
The complainant said on multiple occasions she was not proud of her messages but she had been mirroring his behaviour.
“He would accuse me of being out sucking dicks if I turned my [location] app off after a fight.”
She said she was upset about him being allowed to have female followers and her allegedly not being allowed male followers.
Gray also presented a record of texts showing the complainant sending a message with a single question mark dozens of times, filling up more than nine A4 pages of court documents.
“He would do the same to me,” the complainant said in response.
The defence’s case is that the physical aggression was initiated and spurred on by the complainant and he only used force against her in self-defence.
Gray alleges the man had tried to leave the “toxic” relationship several times and even sought professional help to try to manage the alleged aggression from the woman.
Earlier in the trial the complainant testified their relationship was troubled from the start and described him allegedly being controlling regarding her social media presence.
She claimed he strangled her after she had posted a bikini selfie he didn’t like while on a trip to Bali.
“He grabbed me by the neck, and I think he jammed my arm in the door and I hit my head on the doorframe and I scratched him at some point during this,” she said.
“I was scared.”
Later on the Bali trip, the woman alleged he assaulted her again.
“He strangled me, and he put a pillow over my face because he wanted me to stop talking,” she alleged.
After the holiday she told the court she reported the alleged incidents to police.
“I wanted him to know that I wasn’t kidding when I said ‘you can’t do that', and it is serious, and it wasn’t my fault.”
After the man found out about the report, she told the jury he said she would be “so f***ed” without him.
“I would be nothing without him,” she alleged he said.
At the time the woman said she chose not to take the complaint further.
During the relationship she said she felt like there was an unfair power dynamic between the pair because of his job and because he was more than 20 years her senior.
She said his role as a musician impacted their relationship.
“He would always tie [his prominent music career] in with, ‘You’ll never do better than me‘.”
One of the assault charges specifies a drink bottle was used as a weapon and another charge cites him allegedly biting her.
The musician has also been charged with impeding her normal breathing by applying pressure to her throat. Threatening to kill and threatening to do grievous bodily harm charges were also laid.
Three of the charges were for crimes that allegedly occurred on Boxing Day 2023.
The assault charges where a weapon is not specified carry a maximum of two years imprisonment, the two that include allegations of a weapon hold a maximum of five years in prison.
The charges for threatening to kill, threatening to do grievous bodily harm and impeding normal breathing each carry a maximum of five years imprisonment.
Katie Harris is an Auckland-based journalist who covers social issues including sexual assault, workplace misconduct, media, crime and justice. She joined the Herald in 2020.
Sign up to The Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
