When O'Neill said forcefully, "come here", the girl ran outside yelling "no mummy, no mummy".
O'Neill tried to catch the child but she ran back to her room, her mother following, saying to the nanny: "Don't worry if you hear a scream."
She then turned the girl on her stomach and, ignoring the screams of "no mummy, no", smacked her 10 times on the buttocks and hips, and once in the head.
When the nanny inspected the girl later she had a sore bottom, hips and head, and bright red hand marks were visible on her skin. The marks were still visible on a trip to the doctor four days later.
O'Neill told police it was not the first time that her daughter had been naughty. She had warned her that she had to be punished, and had only smacked her two or three times, O'Neill said.