"I was quite freaked out. I was like, what the hell... this is the end. I've seen shooting stars and comets break up but I have never been so close in my life. It was like looking out at a street light from your house and it looked closer than a street light."
The pair pulled over near an effluent dump station, located near the "Hobbiton turn off" and said they heard a person "come roaring around" on a motorbike.
They were joking about cashing in on the find, and Mr Hodges suggested he should mark the location in his smartphone's GPS.
"The timing was impeccable," said Mr Hodge. "If we'd been a couple of minutes earlier we would have seen it shoot past us... this big blue flame for a short while going straight down with a trail of looked like what sky rockets let off and that stayed in sky for about 10 seconds."
The pair didn't hear a bang to indicate the meteorite landed but because they were still driving at the time they say they may not have felt that.
Mr Mckee was driving when he saw "the really bright light".
"I could see the whole countryside. I saw a streak in the sky and bits of like fireworks but thought it was too bright to be fireworks. It didn't hit me till after that it was cosmic. I've never seen anything like it in my life."
He said the light seemed to head down into a gully.
"I think it landed pretty close to us. It was almost blinding."
Mr Mckee said he had no idea the sighting over the North Island's skies had also lit up social media with speculation as to what the light was.
When Hamilton News spoke with Mr Mckee he had just got home and was "just chilling out with a cigarette".