"If anyone recognises anything about this car or the driver, please get in touch."
The incident happened on Tuesday, at 6.30pm.
A staffer told the Herald this morning they had yet to file a report with police, but had been in touch with local businesses to request CCTV footage of the man and his vehicle.
The worker said there was a bit of a laugh now, among staff members, about the number plates. But with $80 of petrol gone, it was still a serious matter.
"It's definitely a bit cheeky," the staff member said.
"But it's still a bit of a nuisance."
Despite the man's brazen actions, many people found the funny side of the situation.
"That personalised plate is a beaut," one wrote.
"Not the IOU ones," another laughed. Another commentator simply posted the face-palm emoji.
Others, however, sympathised with the pretend customer - acknowledging that it was a sign of the times, given how petrol prices were so high these days.
At least two locals said they had spotted the vehicle in the past two days, complete with the makeshift cardboard "IOU" number plates.
"The plates caught my eye and not him unfortunately," one said.