"NZTA are actually meeting their requirements legally under the Board of Inquiry standards, but it is not fit for purpose for the residents because they're getting sleep disturbance."
Randall wants the commission to determine whether the noise breaches the Human Rights Act.
The 18km expressway, stretching from Mackays to Peka Peka, opened in February.
At the time Transport Minister Simon Bridges said: "It's going to be a road that you are going to love and you are going to benefit from each and every day."
Otaki MP Nathan Guy, who helped cut the opening ribbon, said he had backed the project since it was first mooted.
"I've had constituents in my office in Paraparaumu in tears because they were losing their property. A few years later I've had the odd phone call from those people saying 'Nathan I'm sorry we were so tough on you, we believe this project is the right decision for this region and our community'."