"It's not good."
The boys handed over their phones, along with a Manly Sea Eagles cap one had been wearing.
They made their way home and raised the alarm.
Mr Lynch said detectives had been canvassing residents in the immediate area seeking sightings of the man, or anyone who may have witnessed the robbery.
Meanwhile, police have arrested two people in relation to a similar incident which happened in Napier south early on January 2.
A group of youths were robbed of their cellphones by two men who pulled up in a car about 1am, with one of them believed to have had a firearm.
The pair were arrested on January 12 and appeared in the Napier District Court on January 16 on charges of aggravated robbery. They were remanded in custody to reappear in Napier District Court on February 7.