Mr Sutherland said the valve installation had to be done without any bypasses, so the reservoir had been "as full as we could make it" prior to the work.
Contractors needed to pump water out of the hole to access the valve, which was fixed by 6.30pm. However, demand on the supply meant the council asked people to continue conserving water up to midday today.
A straight pipe was put in meaning the t-valve would need to be redone at a later date.
The reason for the failure was still to be identified and the council would be investigating the rubber ring, Mr Sutherland said.
Despite the break, the council was on track to connect the Taylorville and Dobson supply on time.