Parish vicar Christine Scott said members were delighted to have it back and hear it rung again. "There were people at church who I haven't seen there for a while and they wanted to be there because it was an important occasion."
Ms Scott said the bell was gifted to the parish in the 1970s by an English farming family and she planned to send details of it to Lloyds of London to find out its true value, though an insurance company had put it at $5000.
But it wasn't the monetary value the congregation cared about, Ms Scott said.
"What it means to us, in terms of the connection with the family who gave it, is they can't put a value on it. It's priceless."
Last year, Te Kuiti man Steven Robert Nicol, then 29, pleaded guilty to stealing the bell.