Today, justice finally came.
Christopher Coulter, 36, appeared in the Christchurch District Court where he was jailed for three years for raping the woman, and for indecently assaulting another.
Both previously told Coulter they did not want to have sex with him before he approached them as they slept.
The rape victim’s impact statement was read to the court by a support person and said no words could ever describe the pain and trauma Coulter caused her.
She felt her human rights were violated as she sought justice: “I spent five years waiting, how is that fair?”
“From where I sit, my rapist has more rights than I do.”
It was not said in court why it had taken five years since the offending to reach an outcome.
But as she waited, the woman suffered financially and became homeless for some time, having to sleep in her car.
She suffered from nightmares and anxiety and couldn’t leave the house alone, turning to self-harm as a way to forget what she endured.
“I don’t feel like a victim and I’m not, I’m a survivor who spoke the truth.
“I ask that the judge hears me and gives you the time you took from me [that] I will never get back.”
The second victim described leaving Christchurch as she felt unsafe living in the same area as Coulter.
She said it’s been very hard for her to move forward with her life as she has nightmares and still remembers what he did to her.
The offending
In September 2018, Coulter asked the first victim if she wanted to have sex with him. She said she did not.
That night, she woke to Coulter indecently touching her. She was frozen from fear and pretended to be asleep.
Coulter then raped her.
Between December 2018 and January 2019, Coulter had a conversation with a second victim about sex. She made it clear she did not want to have sex with him.
The woman later fell asleep fully clothed. Coulter pulled her pants and underwear off before indecently assaulting her.
The next day the woman confronted Coulter about what he did through messages. He admitted having “played with her while she was asleep”.
‘Doomed from birth’
At his sentencing, Crown prosecutor Courtney Martyn said even with discounts available to Coulter, a sentence of imprisonment was the only appropriate outcome, highlighting the vulnerability of the victims who were asleep when the offending began.
Coulter’s lawyer Philip Hall KC said the offending was a “one-off” and “out of character” for his client.
He submitted Coulter was neglected as a child and his “life trajectory was almost doomed from birth”.
Coulter suffered post-traumatic stress disorder, intellectual deficiency and clinical anxiety.
Hall asked the judge to impose a sentence of home detention with supervision, stating “home detention is not an easy sentence”.
Judge Paul Kellar said Coulter had caused serious harm, echoing the Crown’s point on the vulnerability of the women.
The judge said both women had made it clear they didn’t want to have sex with Coulter and one woman had taken medication that made her sleepy.
Coulter’s upbringing, particularly the failures of his caregivers, which had led to him making “poor decisions in sexual engagements”, were acknowledged by the judge.
The court heard that Coulter was assessed as a low risk of sexual reoffending and could live a pro-social life if he got the treatment he needed.
The judge gave him discounts for his background, guilty pleas, remorse and willingness to engage in restorative justice, the fact that he had no prior convictions and his prospects for rehabilitation.
Emily Moorhouse is a Christchurch-based Open Justice journalist at NZME. She joined NZME in 2022. Before that, she was at the Christchurch Star.
