The discussions are part of the Government's "Better Local Government" reforms which include an infrastructure expert advisory group looking at water and other issues.
Local Government Minister David Carter said the idea of having fewer water suppliers had not been discussed with him as part of the local government reforms, but he had heard similar ideas from organisations such as Water New Zealand.
Water New Zealand chief executive Murray Gibb said the lobby group supported water rationalisation and had been asked to contribute to the Government's expert advisory group.
Local Government New Zealand declined to comment. A spokesman said there had been a number of studies looking at the delivery of water services over the years.
Auckland Mayor Len Brown has drafted a letter to Watercare board chairman Ross Keenan saying the council is aware of the industry debate on the future of water.
"Council expects that Watercare will not engage in these governance issues as it considers these matters to be the sole prerogative of the shareholder," the letter said.
Mr Keenan said Watercare got involved in operational matters outside Auckland, such as helping with the Christchurch earthquakes, but had always stayed well away from consolidation, ownership and governance matters.
Water, he said, was an extremely sensitive issue with a great fear of privatisation and the safe territory for Watercare was to stay away and let others take the initiative.
Asked if the Watercare model could work elsewhere in New Zealand, Mr Keenan said yes.
He said he had been astonished at the efficiencies and benefits gained through consolidation under Watercare despite initial misgivings.