Surfer and local resident Clint Bishop jumped into the water and tried to encourage him off the rock.
"I just put my jumper on him and tried to get him to jump off the rock. It took about 15 minutes to coax him to jump," Bishop said.
Karekare Surf Life Saving media spokesman Matt Wade said they feared a tragedy because of changes in the beach's sand movement.
"There is a massive dump of sand slowly moving northwards. We are starting to see the impact because, at full tide, you can now get to rocks that used to be inaccessible," Wade said.
"But that means there are rock points which are completely out of sight. If the tide comes in and the swell comes up, the rocks are completely smashed.
"We are worried someone will go out there mid-week and the swell will come up and then there will be a tragedy."
He said swimmers and rock fishermen needed to be more aware of tidal patterns, changing conditions and "watching their escape path".