News of his arrival in Wairarapa was one of the most popular articles online in the last couple of weeks, with 625 Facebook shares.
It also reached 15,352 people via a link posted on the Times-Age Facebook page and was liked by 154 people.
Many online readers, mainly women, wished they had been in Martinborough to catch a glimpse of the 26-year-old.
Samantha Carter said: "Noooo!! I sure can't believe it!! Damn I wish we saw him haha."
Zoe MacKenzie said: "Why didn't you call me Art!! I woulda come lol. I grew up 10 minutes from Martinborough."
Monica Meyrick said: "I'm calling up sick. Let's go see the bachelor if he's still there haha."
Shona Henwood said: "I saw this ... he could've at least come and visited G & I ... two of his compulsive/religious watchers."
Monica Geris said: " I AM MELTING."
Rosemary Rayner said: "What a beautiful family Mark & Sarah, you must be so proud watching Arthur on TV."
A woman who shared the Times-Age's photo of Mr Green said her daughter was quite taken.
Sarah Lee said: "Miss 9 spotted the NZ Bachelor on the balcony of the Martinborough Hotel this morning! She was a little star struck at the sight of him and exclaimed, slightly breathlessly, 'Is that Arthur?!'"