Friday, 08 December 2023
KaitaiaWhangareiDargavilleAucklandThamesTaurangaHamiltonWhakataneRotoruaTokoroaTe KuitiTaumarunuiTaupoGisborneNew PlymouthNapierHastingsDannevirkeWhanganuiPalmerston NorthLevinParaparaumuMastertonWellingtonMotuekaNelsonBlenheimWestportReeftonKaikouraGreymouthHokitikaChristchurchAshburtonTimaruWanakaOamaruQueenstownDunedinGoreInvercargill
NZ HeraldThe Northern AdvocateThe Northland AgeThe AucklanderWaikato HeraldBay Of Plenty TimesRotorua Daily PostHawke's Bay TodayWhanganui ChronicleThe Stratford PressManawatu GuardianKapiti NewsHorowhenua ChronicleTe Awamutu CourierVivaEat WellOneRoofDRIVEN Car GuideThe CountryPhoto SalesiHeart RadioRestaurant Hub
Voyager 2023 media awards
Subscribe
Advertisement
Advertise with NZME.
Home / New Zealand / Crime

Bain case: How compensation claim unravelled

David Fisher
By
David Fisher
26 Jun, 2013 05:30 PM2 mins to read
Saveshare

Share this article

facebookcopy linktwitterlinkedinredditemail
David Bainwas said to be probably innocent by retired Justice Ian Binnie. Photo / Richard Robinson

David Bainwas said to be probably innocent by retired Justice Ian Binnie. Photo / Richard Robinson

It was probable David Bain was innocent, retired Canadian Justice Ian Binnie found.

Justice Binnie found Mr Bain was definitely the victim of a botched police investigation. It was, he said, so bad it constituted "extraordinary circumstances" and Mr Bain should be compensated.

Justice Minister Judith Collins dismissed Justice Binnie's report, calling it "flawed". Mr Bain called a halt on his compensation claim and filed action with the High Court.

Documents released to the Herald under the Official Information Act detail the unravelling of the compensation claim - almost from the moment Justice Binnie's report landed with Mrs Collins last year on August 31.

Advertisement
Advertise with NZME.

Mrs Collins met Justice Binnie two weeks later to tell him she held "serious concerns" and intended to have it peer reviewed. She wrote to retired Justice Robert Fisher, QC, on September 26 asking him to do so.

On December 4, Justice Binnie became concerned over delays in dealing with the compensation.

He wrote to Mrs Collins saying, "I feel obliged to do something." Mrs Collins' office warned the report was privileged - Justice Binnie rejected the claim. Mrs Collins' office then offered an undertaking to release his report after the Cabinet had made a decision on compensation - if he refrained from doing so himself.

On December 11, Mrs Collins moved first. She told Justice Binnie - apparently for the first time - his report had been peer reviewed. She spelled out in a press release the same day her concerns about the report and its "incorrect facts".

Advertisement
Advertise with NZME.

By January 21, when there was talk of yet another report, questions about the process were being raised by Mr Bain's lawyers. Michael Reed, QC, accused Mrs Collins of running a "secret process" which showed a pre-determined view and "abuse of your powers".

Just over a week later, papers were filed in court and the compensation bid halted.

Related articles

New Zealand

Bain fee topped $200k

06 Apr 05:30 PM
New Zealand

Karam defamation case set for later this year

30 Apr 08:45 PM
New Zealand

Bain case: New evidence uncovered

26 Jun 09:30 AM
New Zealand|Crime

Thumb lines point to Robin Bain

26 Jun 05:30 PM
Saveshare

Share this article

facebookcopy linktwitterlinkedinredditemail
Advertisement
Advertise with NZME.

Latest from New Zealand

Crime

Meth addict was 'fried' during 'terrifying' Halloween night armed invasion of stranger's home

08 Dec 07:06 AM
New Zealand

Paraparaumu Beach house fire deemed suspicious

08 Dec 06:46 AM
New Zealand|Crime

Two found guilty of murdering South Auckland grandmother

08 Dec 06:42 AM
New Zealand

One person dead after serious crash in Masterton

08 Dec 06:23 AM

“Never been a better time to buy an EV”

sponsored
Advertisement
Advertise with NZME.

Latest from New Zealand

Meth addict was 'fried' during 'terrifying' Halloween night armed invasion of stranger's home

Meth addict was 'fried' during 'terrifying' Halloween night armed invasion of stranger's home

08 Dec 07:06 AM

Six men claimed to be police then kicked in the door as a petrified woman tried to escape.

Paraparaumu Beach house fire deemed suspicious

Paraparaumu Beach house fire deemed suspicious

08 Dec 06:46 AM
Two found guilty of murdering South Auckland grandmother

Two found guilty of murdering South Auckland grandmother

08 Dec 06:42 AM
One person dead after serious crash in Masterton

One person dead after serious crash in Masterton

08 Dec 06:23 AM
9 big questions over an EV road trip
sponsored

9 big questions over an EV road trip

About NZMEHelp & SupportContact UsSubscribe to NZ HeraldHouse Rules
Manage Your Print SubscriptionNZ Herald E-EditionAdvertise with NZMEBook Your AdPrivacy Policy
Terms of UseCompetition Terms & ConditionsSubscriptions Terms & Conditions
© Copyright 2023 NZME Publishing Limited
TOP