"You can't go back – it turned them as dark as a Sharpie pen.
Charlotte's eyebrows when she had the product on. Photo / Caters News Agency
"I have to fill them in properly now and get them tinted professionally. I don't want to risk it happening again."
Charlotte claims the product stuck to her eyebrows and dyed them black instead of a light brown.
"I had waited for them to grow properly so that they were in a nice shape before I dyed them but it took them both away," Charlotte said.
"Maybelline has a similar one, I thought it must be alright if it was like that one. This one was cheaper, I thought this one was going to be the same.
"I thought it was real when I bought it but now I think it must have been a fake product.
The fake product. Photo / Caters News Agency
"My family were quite shocked and asked me why I used it.
"My friends just laughed at me and my boyfriend watched me cry as I pulled it off."
Etude House confirmed the product was discontinued and, having examined the packaging, believe it's a fake.
Charlotte's brows after peeling the tint off. Photo / Caters News Agency
"The particular product has been discontinued more than a year ago and we are currently not selling the product," an Etude House spokesman.
It’s been an Onslow signature menu item since day one. Now, Josh Emett’s famous crayfish eclair has clawed its way into the Iconic Auckland Eats Top 100 list. Video / Alyse Wright