"I can't remember the number of times I said 'this is so freaky'. It was truly amazing."
Karen, who is currently in between jobs, has five sisters and a brother. Niamh has two sisters, and both girls agree that none of their siblings look anywhere near as similar to them as they do to one another.
Niamh said the pair got on "very well" as they both applied make-up before the shoot, swapping beauty tips and marvelling at their similarities.
"I would say Karen is the shyer of the two of us," Niamh remarked. "But then you have to remember this was an even more surreal experience for her than it was for me.
"I knew what search I was embarking on. I'm the weirdo that contacted Karen out of the blue and asked her to meet me in person."
Since meeting, Niamh and Karen - who are both single - say they've been chatting on Facebook "constantly".
While Niamh appears to have beaten her fellow Twin Strangers participants, 21-year-old Harry and 22-year-old Terence, hands down, the search isn't over until April 27.
"I think I have a two, maybe three at a push who resemble me. But they're definitely not as close a match as Karen to Niamh," Harry says.
"I'm trailing further behind," admits Terence. "Must be a guy thing. They tend to be a bit too shy to participate. Not sure if being originally from sub-Saharan Africa has anything to do with it!"
Niamh, who is still promoting the project across social media with Harry and Terence as interest spreads, says there will be no prize for the winner, just "pride".
They are inviting others from around the world to join in too now, by adding users' photos to their Facebook album.
"There is a huge human curiosity element to it," Niamh states. "Can you imagine how surreal it would be to meet someone who looked exactly like you?"
- Daily Mail