First, they had to be existing "Plunket" babies, born last July so they were the same age as the 10-month-old prince. All parents would be vetted by police before they got the nod to attend, and they had to live in the Wellington area so they were within driving distance of Government House.
Plunket hopes to get a gender balance of five boys and five girls for the event.
The brief was to create an authentic experience for the royal couple so those chosen needed to be able to engage in conversation.
And for this to happen the royals were happily dispensing with protocol about speaking to royals.
The local parents also have to be happy to have their images broadcast the world over as the group will pose with Prince George and his parents for international media before the coffee group meeting, which takes place behind closed doors.
Plunket media manager Nikki Prendergast said the group would be finalised in coming days and participants would receive an official invitation from Government House.
Plunket will give the baby prince his own Plunket book and signature blue bear as a memento.
However, the best laid plains may be torn asunder.
"If he's unwell or grumpy or scratchy on the day we can't guarantee he'll be there," said Prendergast.