"Each recent generation has faced fewer and fewer external pressures to conform to heterosexuality."
Those under 25 are having a "drastically different" experience to older generations as perceptions around sexuality have changed, she said.
A record 5.6 per cent of Americans now identify as LGBTQ, with the majority identifying as bisexual, according to the poll from analytics company Gallup.
Gallup senior editor Jeff Jones said younger generations are "far more likely to consider themselves as something other than heterosexual".
"It reflects what we are seeing in society and the way society is changing.
"The pronounced generational differences raise questions about whether higher LGBT identification in younger than older Americans reflects a true shift in sexual orientation, or if it merely reflects a greater willingness of younger people to identify as LGBT," Jones added.
"To the extent it reflects older Americans not wanting to acknowledge an LGBT orientation, the Gallup estimates may underestimate the actual population prevalence of it."
Last year's survey reported that 86.7 per cent of Americans said they were straight or heterosexual, with 7.6 refusing to answer the question.
Previously, the poll did not ask respondents to identify their exact orientation, only asking for "yes" or "no" responses to whether they were LGBTQ.
After including the more specific question last year, around 54.6 per cent identified as bisexual, 11.7 per cent as lesbian and 11.3 per cent as transgender, with around a quarter identifying as gay.