"OMG CAN'T BELIEVE THIS!! Thank you so much, Virginia and Stephen! I'll need to pop round today and have some xxx."
After Kavanagh saw the comment she panicked and contacted a cakemaker to make a replica cake for the next day, at an eye-watering cost of $380.
Her daughter Lauren shared the hilarious mix-up on Twitter years later and people loved the story.
"Your poor mum, bless her," one wrote.
But the story doesn't end there. Lauren's mother followed up her daughter's post, revealing that Beth hadn't eaten any of the cake.
She said: "Yes poor me!!! I felt so bad for Beth, I wanted to cry!!
"What you failed to add is she then didn't eat the feckin thing and left it at ours to go hard and I was furious!!!"