The picture on Reddit has racked up over 1.6k comments.
READ MORE: • Woman left embarrassed after her mother buys rude cushions • Teen's essay on pizza gets her into Yale
While some of the responses are predictably crude, many of the comments are genuine baking tips on how to improve the appearance of the cookies (eg "It looks like the dough wasn't properly chilled before baking. I always chill the initial dough, and then freeze the cutouts before they go into the oven. Edges turn out great!")
As one commenter said "Came for the penis joke, left with knowledge on baking. We have all grown."
The Reddit user's wife is not the only mum who has accidentally created a slightly rude baked good for a child's birthday. The internet is littered with entertaining images of things that went a little awry.
The cookie calamity comes shortly after a woman posted pictures of the NSFW cushions that her mother had gleefully purchased.