So in a rather desperate attempt to undo his mistake, he emailed everyone at the school (with 26,000 students) who shared her name.
"Hello all Claudia's (sic) of Missouri State," he wrote. "I made a rookie mistake on Tinder. I accidentally swiped left on Claudia's profile (left is bad) and I really wanted to swipe right."
He went on to the describe the profile and ask her to simply respond to the email with "left" or "right" and maybe they could "get some donuts or something".
It's no doubt a pretty desperate move but fortune favours the bold, as they say, because it appears to have paid off.
The story has since gone viral after Claudia shared the email on Twitter, prompting a wide variety of reactions to the romantic gesture.
As some were quick to point out, Tinder offers a premium service for about $20 that would have allowed him to go back and swipe right, which would have been a little less desperate and a lot less public.
While Hayden and Claudia are clearly enjoying their newfound fame on Twitter, most users are eager to know what she replied to the email. But as yet, she hasn't publicly revealed if she plans on getting that doughnut.