But when Rowling gave into temptation and posted a bizarre message reading "Cry, foe! Run amok! Fa awry! My wand won't tolerate this nonsense", wild speculation begun.
Many fans reckon that the riddle refers to Rowling's screenplay for upcoming Harry Potter spinoff movie Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them.
More dedicated analysts on Reddit soon discovered that "New York" and "Newt Scamander" are hidden anagrams in the post, the latter being the main character in the film and the former, its location.
Otherwise, no one has cracked the puzzle, but now plenty of Potter fans are hoping it is a hint that there will be future Harry Potter stories.
Keep up with Rowling's Twitter banter below:
- Independent