"THIS IS HORRIFYING," another added.
Mr Herrington, whose Flickr account contains various images of dolls and figurines, said the Belle doll was "creepy" after spotting the toy while at a JC Penney store at the Mesa Mall in Colorado on Friday.
"I knew that Disney Store's live action dolls are never 100 per cent accurate to the actors, but this one was atrocious!" he told BuzzFeed News.
"Her face was shiny and covered in freckles (that looked more like a skin disease) and her head looked like it was being ripped open and torn where the hair was rooted into the head."
"As for any resemblance to Emma ... yeesh. There really isn't any," he added.
Mr Herrington's post has since gone viral on Twitter and other social media outlets, with some describing the doll as "scary" and looking like Bieber and Watson's love child.
The doll is just one of several released ahead of the film's debut in cinemas worldwide in March 2017.