Covid-19 has forced us to rethink our relationship with food.
For most of us this was in reaction to supermarket shelves being less full than normal or the regularity of shopping visits being curtailed. For others, the economic downturn has forced more people into food insecurity – one in five US households are now unable to access enough food; and a surge in demand is being experienced by foodbanks here.
Sitting alongside scarcity and food insecurity is the rather strange bedfellow of nationalism, and the drive to support local food production. Our social media feeds are full of artisan producers and the mantra of "buy local" is loud and persistent. As consumers, we are grappling with food choices about what we buy, where we buy it and how we can stretch our food dollar further.
There is another food battle that is happening at the same time: the fight for the last mile. This is the hospitality industry's fight for our loyalty as consumers shift focus from bricks and mortar restaurants to the efficacy of home-delivery systems. Which food "app" can get food to consumers quickest, most reliably, and cheapest? Of course, this shift in consumer behaviour brings opportunity for some – for example, a decreased need to invest in expensive real estate to secure food sales, the rise of "ghost kitchens", or the development of local food-delivery services. But we are seeing concerns in other parts of the world over who will "own" the consumer.
While the notion of being "owned" goes against the grain for many consumers, we are entering a period where loyalty is openly talked about and encouraged. Anecdotally, it appears a pandemic is more likely to drive loyalty than any annoying loyalty card.
Everyone is out to understand and capitalise on our shopping behaviours and preferences.
Last year, at the Wall Street Journal's "Future of Food" event in New York, I heard about the concern that large fast-food chains had about losing the consumer to an app platform. In other words, they were concerned a consumer might lose interest in the "brand" of food they were buying and start to rely upon the delivery platform for food choices. When that happens, the ability of large food chains to target consumers is considerably reduced and the ownership of consumer data shifts from the restaurant to the platform.
Along with the potential impacts of distancing from the customer, US restaurants are facing commissions that range from 15 to 40 per cent. While we have seen some debate about the commissions being charged in New Zealand, there is no denying that the cost of developing and maintaining a fleet of drivers (so we can get our burger safely, on time and still hot) is not a cheap endeavour. The big players in the delivery services are playing a long game. Some commentators point to their strategy of expanding and creating dominant platforms which will then be able to maximise service and marketing fees.
That's a sobering strategy when you consider 98 per cent of the delivery services in the US are controlled by four providers. The model of large-scale tech investment that enables a platform to be built to maximise market share could leave us dependent upon a handful of companies for online food purchases in the future.
Salmon-linked Covid-19 outbreak risks causing havoc to food trade
Menulog to undergo rebrand following merger with $12b food delivery giant
These providers have a history of not necessarily looking after the restaurant or consumer. Before Covid-19, one of the platforms was criticised for creating unique phone numbers for orders and then charging the restaurant for use of that number; similarly, a platform purchased up to 23,000 domain names, effectively diverting consumers from some restaurant websites.
The claim of potential hospitality impact may seem a little far-fetched until you consider the collapse of celebrity chef Jamie Oliver's restaurant chain was partially attributed to the changing behaviours of consumers, with the rising trend of ordering food to eat at home while watching Netflix, and that occurred pre-Covid 19. It's likely that, as the restaurant industry rebuilds and energises itself, it will have to contend with changed consumer behaviours and expectations.
Globally, online delivery is tipped to be a $200 billion industry by 2025. A considerable portion of this lies in food delivery in China (between the two largest players about 10 billion food deliveries were recorded there in 2018), But the question needs to be asked about what the true price of this convenience will be.
You can call me old-fashioned, but I am applying my buy-local and support the hospitality industry filter to my food transactions – while I still can.
• Helen Darling has a PhD in Public Health and has been working in food systems for some time. She is co-founder of FoodTruths.org, a New Zealand start-up that is reimagining food systems for the benefit of people and the planet.