Read more: Things we learned from Women Tell All
After breakfast, Mauger and Verhoeven answer some questions. Mauger does most of the talking, but Fleur occasionally chimes in.
Mauger: "The consistency that Fleur had, and what [those moments] meant to me, was the deciding factor."
Verhoeven: "I went into it thinking, 'Whatever will be will be. If it's not meant to be then it's not meant to be'," she says.
While she spouts chirpy cliches, I try to read their body language to decide if they're another Art and Matilda, or a hot, feisty mess like Clare and Jono from Australia's Married At First Sight.
I get nothing. Maybe it's too soon.
After the interview, the mood softens as a Herald photographer sets up his shoot outside the cafe.
The pair use the time to hug, kiss, then talk in tones only audible to them. I definitely feel like a third wheel.
But then, disaster. The photographer's request for Mauger to kiss Verhoeven on the cheek is dismissed as "too cheesy".
Too cheesy? Dude, you're the Bachelor, you're the king of cheese. Give your girl a peck on the cheek.
After all you've put Verhoeven through, it's the least you can do.