"My mum?!" Perry asked, clearly surprised by the apparent non-sequiter.
Then, with a smile and a wink to the camera — perhaps to make Seacrest realise they were live — Perry added: "Well, I hope the apple doesn't fall far from the tree."
Painfully, Seacrest still appeared not to twig that he was being broadcast live on television.
"You are, too. But you're not a mum ... yet," he told her.
"Not yet," Perry said.
"You wanna talk about it?" Seacrest asked.
"Don't start," fellow judge Lionel Richie warned the host.
Eventually, all on screen clocked that they were live on the air — but the very strange exchange left many viewers creeped out:
Seacrest was at the centre of a scandal earlier this year when stylist Suzie Hardy, who worked with the host on E! News, claimed he groped her and gave her a bear hug wearing only his underwear, among other accusations. Seacrest denied the allegations, describing them as "salacious."
The earlier audition episodes of this season of American Idol made headlines due to Perry's 'flirty' judging style — including kissing one young contestant who had confessed he had never kissed anyone before.