The Telegraph's Tim Robey reported that "lift-off, personality, and plainly put, direction, aren't there".
"All the pieces of the movie slide mechanically into place and wait – and wait – for some spark of soul to turn up and animate them."
Mortal Engines by Peter Jackson. Photo / Universal Pictures
Entertainment Weekly says "despite all of the film's retro-future eye candy, it never quite sweeps you out of your seat and transports you someplace new. It's a squeaky salvage job that could have used a fresh dose of oil to make it hum".
Jackson spoke to NZ Herald in June this year and said it was a change for him being the producer, not the director on this film - he tapped longtime protege Christian Rivers to helm.
"I was intending to direct but then The Hobbit came along," Jackson explains. "I've worked with Christian for 25 years and I just thought it would be great to give him a chance to shoot it."
Mortal Engines was shot in Wellington and stars Hugo Weaving and Hera Hilmar.
It is based on a book by Philip Reeve about a post-apocalyptic steampunk world.