The original tickets sold for just $89.90-$109.90 each.
One fan went so far as rallying for a petition to get Ticketmaster to ban the resale of tickets at such high prices.
"J. Cole tickets went on sale at 12pm, by 12.02pm people were already reselling $110 tickets for over $500, now the cheapest sold out GA ticket being resold is $1150," they claimed.
"Share this post so ticketmaster can revoke all of those tickets so real fans can have them."
Another suggested a cap on resale prices saying "You [Ticketmaster] have the ability to change this and support your core customer. The person who actually wants to go to a concert. Support us. Support the artist. Ban the scalper."
Ticketmaster told Radio New Zealand that demand for J. Cole tickets was "huge" and that there were always going to be people who missed out, adding that they "never place tickets on secondary market sites".
The official Ticketmaster Facebook page responded to one fan's concerns saying simply: "Everyone is at the computer at the same time as you are. When everyone clicks buy now, and there is more demand for tickets than there are seats, then this is what happens."
J. Cole will play Auckland's sold out Vector Arena on Friday, December 1.