Cohen had more success pranking Simpson, the former NFL running back who in 1995 was found not guilty in the murder of his ex-wife, Nicole Brown, and her friend Ron Goldman. In a hidden camera segment, Cohen appeared as Gio Monaldo, an outlandish Italian photographer, who was flanked by a woman Simpson repeatedly called "gorgeous."
Monaldo, in Cohen's faux Italian accent, introduced Simpson to his companion as a former player for "the Buffalo Billah," but she didn't get the reference. Nor did she draw a connection when Monaldo brought up Simpson's appearances in the Naked Gun franchise. It wasn't until Monaldo feigned a stabbing motion toward her neck that she recognised Simpson: "Oh mama mia, O.J.," she said before extending her hand to greet him. "So nice to meet you!"
When the woman left the room, Simpson told Monaldo that she was gorgeous, and Cohen's character agreed, but added "sometimes I want to kill her."
"Hey," Simpson said, laughing nervously. "Stop. Stop."
Monaldo laughed as he suggested various ways he might kill his girlfriend. "Maybe I send her on a bungee jump, you know, oh the cord!"
"Cord extra long," Simpson offered. "Bang!"
At one point, Monaldo told Simpson of a friend who was "obsessed with what happened that night with the wife" and said the friend wanted to talk to him about it. "We want you to be 100 per cent truthful about how you got away with it," Monaldo added.
"Hey, hey, I didn't get away with nothing," Simpson said.
"Me and you, we got something in common," Monaldo told Simpson. "We both, how you say, lady killers? You know, it's not what it sounds like. In Italian it translates to 'somebody who, uh, murders women.'"
"No, I ain't kill nobody," Simpson said, laughing.
Sunday's episode notably did not include a segment featuring former Alaska governor Sarah Palin, who said ahead of the show's July premiere that she had been tricked into a bogus interview with Cohen. Palin said Cohen was "heavily disguised" as a disabled U.S. veteran with "a fake wheelchair." A Twitter account for Cohen's Ruddick character appeared to confirm the Palin prank, but Showtime disputed her claim that Cohen used a fake wheelchair. As Ruddick, Cohen appeared on a motorised scooter throughout the series.
While it appears the Palin segment will not be seen, Cohen did give a nod to the former vice presidential candidate in the finale credits, recognising her as a "special publicity consultant (inadvertent)."
Who Is America is available to stream on Neon.