Cole anxiously questioned whether the crowd would know early hits from his 2009 mixtape The Warm Up, and was shocked when one loyal fan appeared on the arena's screens singing the track word-for-word as Cole spat out the hit.
Cole took a second to thank the fans and declared it's "not right to assume" that Kiwis wouldn't know his full discography.
"I can't assume shit but if you were there for that one, I can assume you were there for this one" before launching into Work Out and on to Forbidden Fruit.
Later, following an energetic performance of Neighbours, Cole revealed the inspiration behind the track - and the entire live show set-up.
CCTV footage lit up the screens on stage showing a large SWAT team surrounding his house, kicking down doors and disabling security cameras, sending the crowd into roaring chants of "FTP" (f*** the police).
In an effort to calm the crowd, Cole thanked them for their support before the arena was lit up by cellphones for Love Yourz and popular hit Wet Dreamz as the crowd mellowed.
Ending his show on a high-note, he burst into 2014 Forest Hill Drive hit No Role Modelz and encouraged the crowd to always show peace and love.
When J Cole was last here in 2014 he opened for Eminem as part of the Rapture event at Western Springs. This time his own tour at Auckland's Spark Arena was a sell-out and it's clear to see why as Kiwis resonated with every word and every lyric the rapper sent across the stadium.