Of the 37 reviews aggregated so far on MetaCritic.com, 35 are positive, and the remaining two are mixed. A whopping 10 of those critics give Abrams's film a perfect "100" score, with Calvin Wilson of the St. Louis Post Dispatch writing: "Perhaps the greatest triumph of Star Wars: The Force Awakens is that it justifies the enormous hype." No small feat, that.
The old-school-meets-new-vigor judgment is commonly shared. Wilson says the directer "brings fresh energy to the franchise while adhering to the storytelling values that made it matter in the first place."
The Boston Globe's Ty Burr emphasizes that a powerful blast of memory and nostalgia is stronger than anything nitty-gritty emitted by a Star Wars blaster gun: "Abrams understands what George Lucas never quite figured out: that we're less interested in the science fiction future than we are in revisiting the past."
The Hollywood Reporter's Todd McCarthy writes that Abrams infuses this "hallowed franchise" with a fresh energy "in a way that both resurrects old pleasures and points in promising new directions."
Associated Press reviewer Lindsey Bahr senses storyteling repetition - not that there's anything wrong with that. " Star Wars: The Force Awakens is no more and no less than the movie that made us love it in the first place," Bahr writes. "In fact, it's basically the same thing. Isn't that what we all wanted anyway?"
Ann Hornaday, The Washington Post's chief film critic, spells out the specifics of Abrams's sheer achievement, writing: "The Force Awakens strikes all the right chords, emotional and narrative, to feel both familiar and exhilaratingly new. Filled with incident, movement and speed, dusted with light layers of tarnished 'used future' grime, it captures the kinetic energy that made the first film, from 1977, such a revelation to filmgoers who marveled at Lucas's mashup of B movies, Saturday-morning serials, Japanese historical epics and mythic heft."
And Helen O'Hara of Empire offers a particularly succinct verdict:
"The prequels this ain't. We can all breathe again."