It was like that all night, as the Foo Fighters-infused anthemic rock of Days Go By, shouty punk of All I Want and frenetically-paced Kids Aren't All Right hit all the right notes, but were let down by Hit That's nursery rhyme hook, Why Don't You Get a Job's silly simplicity and the acoustic cowbell-infused rock of Spare Me the Details.
And the jury is still out on Pretty Fly (For a White Guy), the band's chart-topping single from 1998 which contains one of Noodles' best hooks, but the lyrics - which name check Vanilla Ice and Ricki Lake - haven't aged well.
If you haven't seen the band perform live since they were last here in 1999, there's plenty of good news: front man Dexter Holland's voice sounds exactly like it did 20 years ago; they played four tracks from their best album, 1994's Smash; and the sound levels at Vector Arena were near perfect.
And they thankfully left Cruising California (Bumpin' in my Trunk) - a ridiculous rap track from last year's Days Go By album that has been a staple of recent live shows - off the setlist. Dodged a bullet there, New Zealand.
But the Offspring nailed several key moments when it counted, like set highlight and compulsory singalong Gone Away, the still-awesome chorus of Come Out and Play (Keep 'Em Separated) and set closer Self Esteem - a song sung so loudly by the crowd all Holland could do was stand there and smile.
All in all, the Offspring are still pretty fly - just not as often as they could be.
What: The Offspring, Billy Talent and Villainy
Where: Vector Arena, Auckland
When: Wednesday, February 27