Few could separate Winter and Schwarz - an Auckland mother who gave up seeing her daughter's first birthday to appear on the show - and a poll on nzherald.co.nz was split between the two. With 4500 votes, the results were 50-50 for the question, Who'll take the MasterChef crown tonight?
Winter's crowning came after four bruising final challenges, including the toughest this season: A multi-layered "torturous" trifle - or "triflezilla" as Winter described it - dessert that took three hours to make.
Despite getting a layer in the wrong order and undercooking her meringue, Winter took out the trifle challenge thanks to her immaculate presentation - leaving her ahead of Schwarz in points and giving her the crown.
"Chelsea, from the venison to the trifle - in this final you have made MasterChef dishes all the way," said judge Simon Gault, who said he wanted to put her peppered carpaccio venison entrée with pickled vegetables on his menu at Euro.
"You are the deserving winner."
Winter said she wanted to use her win to realise her dream - opening her own restaurant.
"This competition has ignited a spark in me. It's just gone 'whoomph' and it's in full flame now," she said.
Winter takes home more than $100,000 worth of prizes, and will release her own MasterChef-inspired cookbook in the coming months.
* Visit nzherald.co.nz tomorrow for a full interview with Chelsea Winter.