The post, which has now been shared thousands of times, even caught the attention of Lively herself, who cheekily tweeted "My secret is out …"
The Green Lantern star, 30, also shared the picture on her Instagram, where she quipped: "Pretending to be someone else … since 1997 (Thanks @briaaamadrid for the photo of us at the Spice Girls concert. Sorry-not-sorry I tricked you into thinking I was @emmaleebunton."
And if you thought the whole situation couldn't get any cooler, Baby Spice also chimed in, responding to Lively's Instagram post.
"So cute, you're rocking those pigtails @blakelively," she wrote.
If this isn't an excuse to dust off those old photo albums then what is?