"I just walked and opened up the door. Then they said: 'Open the front screen door.' They say do it with one hand so then I have to do it with one hand. My hands are up and they have me outside."
Rhames said the officer pointing the gun at him was joined by two other officers as well as a police dog and the chief of police, who recognized the Golden Globe winner and instructed the officers stand down.
The officers revealed they were responding to a 911 call from a neighbor who said a "large black man" had broken into a home.
Rhames accompanied the officers across the street to confront the neighbor who made the call, but she denied it, according to Rhames.
"You can check this with the Santa Monica Police Department. They apologized and what have you. This is the God's honest truth," he said.
A spokesperson at the department responded to Rhames' claims saying the incident actually occurred in July 2016, according to The Blast.
At the time there had reportedly been multiple violent home invasions in the area, so the police response following the call about Rhames' house was 'appropriate'.
The spokesperson also said the situation with Rhames led to the establishment of a program called 'Meet Your Neighbors' to strengthen bonds within the community through meet-and-greet events.
The department has not returned DailyMail.com's requests for comment.
Ultimately Rhames said he feels lucky that the situation was diffused so quickly, but that the experience made him worry about his 16-year-old son Freedom.
"My problem is, as I said this to them, what if it was my son and he had a video game remote or something and you thought it was a gun?" Rhames asked.