Democrats on Monday blocked a US$2 trillion coronavirus rescue bill for the second day in a row as near-pandemonium erupted on the Senate floor, with lawmakers venting fury about their failed efforts to address the pandemic's impact on the US economy.
Ahead of the vote, senators clashed angrily over delays that had bogged down the giant bill, reflecting uncertainty about whether Congress would be able to reach a deal in the coming hours or days. Some lawmakers had hoped to reach an agreement three days ago, but talks kept breaking down even as they negotiated throughout the weekend. Meanwhile, the nation is reeling from the health consequences and economic pain inflicted by the virus as hope of a swift response from Congress appeared to drain away.
• Coronavirus: World markets see-saw as volatility continues
• Covid 19 coronavirus: NZ share market falls more than 10 per cent for first time ever
• Covid-19 coronavirus lockdown: Uncertainty sweeps over housing market
• 'Surreal' Hawke's Bay Farmers' Market held with new coronavirus measures
Democrats have argued that the Senate GOP bill is disproportionately tilted toward helping companies and needs to extend more benefits to families and health care providers. Republicans have countered that the bill - which would send checks to many individual Americans while creating giant loan programs for small businesses and industry - offers unprecedented financial assistance to the entire economy and needs to be passed before more people lose their jobs.
The vote Monday was 49-46, well short of the 60-vote threshold needed to advance the legislation for a final debate.
"This has got to stop and today is the day it has to stop," an exasperated Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., said. "The country is out of time."
McConnell accused Democrats of holding up the sorely needed rescue package so they can try to add extraneous provisions sought by special interests and organised labour. Democrats have refused to support the key procedural vote that would have made it easier to pass the bill, with many complaining that the legislation did not include much transparency into which businesses could receive hundreds of billions of dollars in emergency loans.
Sen. Joe Manchin III, D-W.Va., said that the bill, which includes a huge $500 billion program for businesses, states, and cities makes the Senate look "more focused on the big corporations and the health of Wall Street than we are on the health care of the people in rural America and Main Street." The Trump administration would have wide latitude to disburse these loans and loan guarantees, a dynamic that has given numerous Democrats pause.
Minority Leader Charles Schumer, D-N.Y., insisted he is continuing to negotiate in good faith with Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin and hopes to secure a deal as long as he can ensure worker protections are included, and that the fund for industries has appropriate controls.
"We have an obligation to get the details right, get them done quickly," Schumer said. "That doesn't mean blindly accepting a Republican-only bill."
As markets fell on Monday, the Senate floor then descended into an uproar as Sen. Susan Collins, R-Maine, sought recognition to speak, which Schumer objected to, prompting Sen. Tom Cotton, R-Ark., to exclaim, "This is bullshit!" and Collins to say, "This is unbelievable."
Schumer then argued with Sen. Ben Sasse, R-Neb., who was presiding over the Senate, to get recognized and get McConnell to explain the schedule ahead. Once that happened, the Senate agreed to proceed to a repeat of Sunday's procedural vote, only to have it fail again.
The fireworks weren't over on the floor as Manchin and McConnell got into it, with McConnell lecturing Manchin about Senate process in an unusual exchange.
Summing it all up was Sen. John Neely Kennedy, R-La., who took his turn on the Senate floor, shaking his head before declaring, "This country was founded by geniuses but it's being run by a bunch of idiots."
"You know what the American people are thinking right now?" Kennedy inquired rhetorically. "They're thinking that the brain is an amazing organ. It starts working in a mother's womb and it doesn't stop working until you get elected to Congress."
The fiery developments reflected rising tensions among lawmakers over the nation's predicament and what's happening in the Senate itself, where Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky., announced Sunday he has covid-19 and four other GOP senators are quarantined. Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., disclosed Monday that her husband, too, is infected with the virus.
The Dow Jones industrial average has lost more than 10,000 points in six weeks, and several million Americans have already lost their jobs as the economy contracts in the face of the coronavirus outbreak. A growing number of states are directing citizens to stay home to avoid more contagion, putting pressure on businesses who are losing workers and customers. Scores of companies have rushed to Washington seeking emergency assistance, and health care providers are overrun with the need for testing kits and safety equipment.
Sen. Richard Durbin, D-Ill., advised everyone to "assume the appropriate distance and take a deep breath" and also said the Senate needed to figure out how to vote remotely, something McConnell has opposed. "We should not be physically present on this floor at this moment," Durbin said.
The situation was fluid and uncertain, but Mnuchin continued to insist progress was being made and a deal was in reach - essentially the same thing he's been saying over three days of ultimately unsuccessful efforts.
"We are getting there. We are very close," Mnuchin said as he exited a late afternoon meeting with McConnell, which was preceded by a meeting with Schumer.
The legislation aims to pour money into all corners of the economy, from individuals to small businesses to large industries amid a wave of layoffs and a sharp contraction in consumer spending. It would direct $1,200 to most adults and $500 to most children. It would also create a $500 billion lending program for businesses, cities and states and another $350 billion to help small businesses meet payroll costs.
Democratic concerns have focused on the $500 billion funding program for loans and loan guarantees Republicans want to create, which some Democrats are labelling a "slush fund" because the Treasury Department would have broad discretion over who receives the money. There is little precedent for a program with a similar size and scope.
Even as senators were clashing Monday on one side of the Capitol, on the other side House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., was holding a news conference to unveil House Democrats' version of the stimulus bill. Pelosi's $2.5 trillion-plus bill would send $1,500 to individual Americans, pump money into the health care system, unemployment insurance and schools and - according to a draft circulating Monday - require airlines and other companies that receive aid to pay a $15-an-hour minimum wage.
"Democrats take responsibility for our workers," Pelosi said. "We require that any corporation that takes taxpayer dollars must protect their workers' wages and benefits - not CEO pay, stock buybacks or layoffs."
But if the House charts its own course on a competing piece of legislation, it could take even longer to arrive at a bipartisan consensus that can pass both chambers and get signed into law.
With more than 40,000 confirmed covid-19 cases in the United States, the impacts of the crisis were growing worse.
The $500 billion in loan programs in the Senate bill includes $425 billion for companies, states and cities, though it doesn't prescribe many terms to dictate how Treasury determines who receives the assistance. Another $50 billion would go to helping passenger airline companies, $8 billion for cargo air companies and $17 billion to help firms deemed important for national security. And there would be an additional $350 billion in loan guarantees for small businesses to help them avoid layoffs, and many of those loans could be forgiven if firms meet certain metrics.
At the insistence of Democrats, who were participating in drafting the bill before bipartisan talks broke down over the weekend, more than $100 billion is being included for hospitals and some $250 billion to boost unemployment insurance. The sweeping economic package is designed to last for 10 to 12 weeks, after which the administration could revisit whether it would seek additional assistance from Congress.
The huge economic stimulus bill now under negotiation is Congress' third attempt to address the coronavirus crisis. As the scope of the crisis started coming into focus early this month, Congress passed $8.3 billion in emergency spending for the public health system. Then Mnuchin and Pelosi negotiated a $100-billion-plus package that included paid sick leave, a Medicaid expansion, free vaccines and more, which the Senate passed last week despite misgivings voiced by many Senate Republicans over the structure of the paid sick leave program.
Along the way, intermittent bipartisanship has given way to occasional partisan outbursts, but partisan rancour now seems to have largely overtaken the process.
- Washington Post