De Haan claims Pack & Send was aware of his artwork's value and fragility when it picked it up, but at that point he'd not been given any paperwork relating to either payment or insurance.
"We've sent lots of stuff internationally, and if it's high value you expect to pay a higher insurance premium".
He says he couldn't get any response from Pack & Send's local franchisee, but then eventually tracked down the company's managing director, Matthew Everest.
De Haan was offered only $6000, which he refused – "they stated that is the maximum I'm entitled to by law".
He believes the company's morally obligated to stump up the replacement cost.
"I think it's cheeky that they think they can walk away from it without even offering me some sort of agreeable compensation.
"I've even said to them, 'look, I'm happy to talk about a payment plan if they don't feel they can pay it off in one go'."
In an email to Mountain Scene, Everest says "this was a very unfortunate event", however he understands the Queenstown franchisee's negotiating with De Haan "to come to a satisfactory resolution".
He says the company's in the final throes of sorting out an insurance claim with an insurer.
"As part of the process, the insurer was legally obligated to offer the $6000 as part of the Carriage of Goods Act, now part of the Commerce Act.
"Obviously, this is a long way from the amount Ben was seeking, and naturally [he] refused the offer."
Everest says the fact the process has taken some time "is also unfortunate".
De Haan says he's been waiting for four months "so we'll see".
Late last year De Haan sold his unique Arthurs Point home, 'Sawtooth House', for $4.35 million.
