We can perhaps learn something from author Charles Duhigg, who wrote the book The Power of Habit. He talked about success coming from training ourselves to stick to good habits (such as investing well and infrequently) rather than defaulting to poor habits.
He gave an example of former NFL coach Tony Dungy, who constantly missed out on promotion because of his coaching philosophy. Dungy believed the key to winning was changing players' habits so they stopped making decisions during a game and instead reacted automatically and habitually. He said: "Champions don't do extraordinary things, they do ordinary things but they do them without thinking. They follow the habit they've learned."
He had some success with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, but the philosophy broke down in big games where the players would put their habits to one side in the belief that they had to "step it up". In these big games, the players' conscious efforts and active decisions led to more losses than when they relied on being ordinary and acting automatically.
Being an "ordinary" investor can be extremely satisfying. I have had great experiences by buying well and then letting my investments generate results. While I may not have enjoyed the bragging rights that come from picking the investment du jour, I did get the satisfaction of comparing the value of my "boring" investments to my entry price and marvelling at the long-term gains. Not only that, but I could relax, knowing that the management of my investment was in good hands and I was unlikely to get any surprises.
With many high-octane investments, short-term success can lead to big expectations, such that any disappointment or stumble results in an outsized share-price reaction.
Who wants to be on tenterhooks waiting to see if the market's expectations are going to be met? It's much nicer to sit back and let the ordinary become the extraordinary over time, without having to lift a finger or an eyebrow.
-This column is presented in association with Fisher Funds.