New Zealand's banks were called to Wellington this week to address concerns about their behaviour in the wake of the Australian inquiry into banking misconduct. Below is the letter that regulators, the Financial Markets Authority and the Reserve Bank, sent bank bosses.
To the Chief Executives of NZ Banks and NZBA,
Thank you for meeting with us on Monday evening.
It was positive to hear the expressions of concern in relation to issues raised at the Royal Commission.
As we said at the meeting, we both believe that the nature and extent of the issues within financial services in Australia and the obvious cross-over in terms of entities, people and practices into New Zealand demands a strong response from the industry here and from the regulators.
We would like to set out the expectations of the FMA and the Reserve Bank as to next steps and to clarify the information and actions required from your organisation.
Our objective in this exercise is to understand what work you have undertaken to review your operations to promptly identify and address any conduct and culture issues.
We expect you to show us what you have done in order to be comfortable that there are no material conduct issues within your business.
We anticipate that you will have undertaken an exercise of that nature after our Conduct Guide (published in February 2017) and may be extending or enhancing that work in response to issues raised at the Royal Commission or more broadly as a result of that inquiry.
As we discussed on Monday, the window for you to demonstrate to consumers, regulators and other stakeholders that they can have full confidence in the financial services industry in New Zealand is narrow, and we encourage proactive leadership from the retail Banking sector.
Aspects of banking conduct and culture fall within the regulatory remit of both the Reserve Bank and the Commerce Commission.
This letter has been shared with and has the support of the Commerce Commission. In addition, we advise that the responses we seek from you will be shared with both of these agencies.
Your response We acknowledge that we have already received initial responses from some Banks which vary in the extent to which they outline specific work already undertaken or more recently underway.
We would comment that an open invitation from Banks to us to come and look at their operations is not sufficient. We reserve the right to conduct on-site monitoring as and when we feel it is necessary (including in response to material that you provide us) but the purpose of this exercise is to understand how you as leaders of your businesses have obtained assurance that misconduct of the type highlighted in Australia is not taking place here.
To clarify, we request a written response from your organisation outlining:
• The actions you, your Board and your senior teams have taken to identify and address conduct risk – including any "gap analysis" work against the expectations set out in the FMA's Conduct Guide
• Any specific plans and actions you have taken (or have underway) to respond to the issues and themes arising from the Royal Commission
• Any other work you have underway or that is planned to proactively identify and address potential conduct and culture risk • Any work underway to remediate any identified issues where bank conduct has resulted in detrimental outcomes for customers.
• We envisage receiving from you a summary document that provides an overview of your programme of work including:
• the key objectives of your work • structure, approach and level of resourcing of your work • level of Board and senior management oversight and reporting • key personnel involved • summary of any early findings/insights to date • details of any remediation programmes underway • any other summary information that will help to provide us with a view on level and depth and focus areas of your current inquiries.
Please provide this overview to the FMA no later than Friday 18 May 2018. We will then assess this summary information and schedule a follow up meeting with your core team to discuss your response, agree next steps, timetable, further information requests and ongoing reporting.
We will also work with you to schedule a meeting with your Board of Directors to discuss this work. We intend to be fully open and transparent in our inquiries and interactions with you and we expect the same approach from your organisations.
We encourage early discussion of any areas where you anticipate that some remediation may be appropriate or where you are considering changes to product offerings, sales practices or business structures We will also continue to focus on areas we have previously signalled as priorities, including:
• the FMA's thematic review on soft commission in life insurance the Financial Adviser Act reforms • the FMA's thematic work on incentives in vertically integrated institutions
• QFE Insurance provider replacement business
• Follow up initiatives from the Reserve Bank's 2017 Bank Director Attestation Review
• Our stakeholder relationship management programme – we anticipate deepening our priority focus this year on governance and culture within financial services firms. Please also share this letter with your Boards of Directors. We will publish this letter on our website in the interests of transparency.
Yours sincerely, Rob Everett Chief Executive Financial Markets Authority [and] Adrian Orr Governor Reserve Bank of New Zealand