The store will now close on March 20 and reopen a Pizza Hut takeaway store on the edge of the New Lynn mall.
Despite being overwhelmed by customers wanting to relive the experience, not all Pizza Hut goers were happy. One diner, Jared Veale, said despite fond memories of the restaurant, it was "not worth the visit".
"To all who thought they would try to re-live the nostalgia of dine-in Pizza Hut by going to the last remaining one before it closes down, I can tell you right now - don't even bother," Veale said.
"We tried to go last night and were greeted by about 10 or 12 people battling over three pizzas and one lady complaining that she wanted a refund."
Veale said his group were eventually told they would have to wait a minimum of 15 minutes before being let in, and would then have just 15 minutes to eat before having to leave.
"They seemed to be bringing out the bare minimum amount of pizzas that they could get away with and I didn't see any desert, although I didn't actually get all the way in," Veale said. "We decided it wasn't worth it."
The last remaining restaurant in Auckland's New Lynn was also the first of the chain to open in New Zealand in 1974 and has been running for 41 years.
Pizza Hut is owned by Restaurant Brands which also operated the KFC, Carl's Jr and Starbucks brands. The company has owned and operated Pizza Hut since 1997 when it took over from Pepsico.