"They also have a higher average price with $1.4m for a unrenovated property."
O'Hanlon said there was more opportunity in more affordable areas such as Mt Wellington.
Housing stock in the east Auckland suburb provided the best starting point for those keen on investing in home improvements, he said. Improvements made to modern properties saw a 46 per cent increase with the average sale price increasing from $530,000 to $770,000. More established properties in the area saw an increase of 31 per cent when renovated.
The average sale price for those properties increased from $800,000 for an unrenovated house to $1.05 million when renovated.
Mangere Bridge also provided plenty of do-up properties, with 15 of the sales in 2016 made up of unrenovated properties.
Unrenovated homes sold for an average price of $862,200.
Renovated homes sold for $150,000 more at just over $1m.
Historic properties, built before 1940, that have been renovated to a "good" condition command a 38 per cent price premium over properties where the walls and/or the roof require repairs.
"Perhaps the 47 per cent uplift of 1930s villas will help investors avoid bowling some of these iconic homes once the unitary plan kicks in," O'Hanlon said.