Meme stock Bed Bath & Beyond tumbles after influential investor bails out

Some hoped the famous investor would send Bed Bath & Beyond's stock soaring like GameStop's did early last year. Photo / 123RF

The newest meme stock on Wall Street, Bed Bath & Beyond, is tumbling even further in after-hours trading Thursday after a high-profile activist investor confirmed that's he's bailed out of the stock.

Ryan Cohen, the co-founder of Chewy, who helped ignite a couple of meme stocks to jaw-dropping heights, confirmed in a filing with U.S. regulators that he no longer owns any shares or options related to Bed Bath & Beyond's stock.

The move disappointed hordes of smaller-pocketed and novice investors, who had piled into the stock amid hopes Cohen could turn around the company's struggling finances, or at least send its stock on a moonshot like GameStop's early last year.

Bed Bath & Beyond's stock dropped nearly 35 per cent in after-hours trading, after it had already sank nearly 20 per cent during the regular session to close at $18.55.

The steep drop follows a monstrous run from $5.77 at the start of the month to $23.08 on Tuesday, which Wall Street analysts saw as irrational.

Cohen sold all of the nearly 7.8 million shares he held in Bed Bath & Beyond on Tuesday and Wednesday, at prices between $18.68 and $29.22.

He also sold options tied to the stock. In March, he first revealed that he had built a nearly 10 per cent stake in Bed Bath & Beyond, with shares purchased at prices between $13.08 and $17.10.

Investors on Reddit's WallStreetBets forum, a hub of discussion for the stock, were trying to gauge their next steps in what one commenter called "BLOOD BATH AND BEYOND."

"How many times are 'meme traders' going to keep mindlessly gambling on false prophets instead of actually learning how to invest and trade?" one commenter wrote.

Cohen was a big reason many investors piled into Bed Bath & Beyond, particularly after his earlier investment in GameStop helped that stock soar to heights that stunned all of Wall Street.

As Bed Bath & Beyond's stock kept going higher in recent days, many voices on Reddit and other social media sites urged other investors to keep buying. Along the way, some revelled in facing down the professional investors who had bet Bed Bath & Beyond's stock would fall.

Despite all the furore, Bed Bath & Beyond continues to lose money as it struggles to navigate the post-pandemic retail landscape.

Bed Bath & Beyond fired CEO Mark Tritton in June after the company based in Union, New Jersey, reported a 25 per cent drop-off in sales in its most recent quarter, which followed a 22 per cent sales decline the previous quarter.

Tritton, who as CEO of Target revitalised that retailer by introducing a bevy of new brands, laid out a similar plan for Bed Bath & Beyond in 2021, but with less success.