This followed a police investigation which disclosed Nicholls had contingent interests in various properties.
Read more:
• Police target more assets of jailed finance director
• Capital + Merchant men get parole
Rather than argue the case in-front of a judge, the police, Nicholls and the legal holders of that property have now reached an out-of-court settlement over the assets.
This means property worth around $1.8 million will now be forfeited to the Crown.
The settlement was approved this month by the High Court's Justice Christian Whata, who said the agreement was " a common sense compromise" that served the overall interests of justice.
Suppression orders, however, remain in place over many of the details of the settlement.
Assets associated with former C+M director Wayne Douglas - Nicholls' partner-in-crime - have also been forfeited to the Crown and police last year cut a deal with the owners of two properties linked to him.
A profit forfeiture order was made in connection with a Whangaparaoa property, with a capital value of $560,000 as of 2011 and which was bought by Douglas in 2008. The deal meant another property linked to Douglas, with a capital value of $1.5 million, was removed from the scope of police restraining orders.
Douglas was sentenced to a jail term of eight years and two months and is also out on parole. The action against his assets was the first time the police had targeted property tied to a failed finance company director.