"Council staff continue to have a culture of no consultation, closed-door meetings and hook-ups for the boys," Mr Lawrenson said.
" And the disrespect shown to hardworking business people throughout the city is no different to the decision-making processes that were followed during the V8s all those years ago."
He said he was not against having a fan zone, but felt the revamped Garden Place was the best place for it.
Cullens Restaurant owner Andrew Cullen said road closures killed his business and benefited only the bars.
"We are absolutely dead against it. It affects our business so, so much when Hood St is closed. It's absolutely awful - it seems to me the big bars on Hood St, and we are talking about the Phoenix Group ... dictate the opening hours of when the street's going to close.
Coffee and Food Establishment cafe owner Todd Lawrence said his turnover would drop about 80 per cent if the road was closed from Saturday morning.
But Hamilton City Council general manager of events and economic development Sean Murray said the council was asked to approve a proposal to close the road for an entertainment zone from the Phoenix Group and he questioned what other consultation was required.
Yesterday he was unaware of any other complaints from businesses on the street.
Phoenix Group director Jason Macklow said it was only one business owner opposing the closure.