McCarthy said portfolio managers often sell down other holdings when a placement like Goodman's occurs.
Other property stocks came in for some heavy trading, with Kiwi Property down 2.1 per cent at $1.615 on a volume of 3.7 million shares. That made it the day's most traded stock, at more than twice its 90-day average of 1.7 million shares.
Stride fell 0.9 per cent to $2.28 with 1.6 million shares traded, and Precinct increased 0.6 per cent to $1.80 on a volume of 1.3 million shares. Property For Industry slipped 1 per cent to $2.37 with 703,000 shares changing hands.
A2 Milk led the market lower, down 3.9 per cent at $13.70 on a volume of 1.2 million shares, more than its 798,000 average. The milk marketing firm hasn't enjoyed the same boost as other infant formula companies since ASX-listed Bellamy's Australia received a A$1.5 billion ($1.6b) takeover offer. A2 closed at a six-month low today.
"I'm a little surprised to see A2 hit the way it has been. I would have thought Bellamy's take-out would have lent more support to a top performer like A2 than it has been," McCarthy said.
Synlait Milk gave up some of its recent gains, down 2.1 per cent at $9.30 and Fonterra Shareholders' Fund dipped 0.3 per cent to $3.20.
Kathmandu Holdings jumped 6.8 per cent to $2.98, its highest close since October. The retailer reported earnings at the top end of its upgraded guidance, with a stand-out performance from its Oboz footwear unit in the US. Some 661,000 shares changed hands, more than its 175,000 average.
Stocks across Asia were mixed, China's Shanghai Composite Index up 0.3 per cent in afternoon trading, Australia's S&P/ASX 200 Index down 0.3 per cent and South Korea's Kospi 200 index rising 0.6 per cent. McCarthy said New Zealand's market initially followed a strong lead from Northern hemisphere trading but tapered off through the session.
Of other companies trading on volumes of more than a million shares, Spark New Zealand rose 1 per cent to $4.52, Arvida Group was unchanged at $1.43, and Meridian Energy fell 1 per cent to $5.10. Auckland International Airport was down 1.8 per cent at $8.96, the first time it's closed below $9 since mid-June.
Refining NZ was unchanged at $2.10 after reporting its highest processing margin in 18 months.
Outside the benchmark index, several companies held their annual meetings. Of those, Evolve Education rose 5.5 per cent to 11.5 cents, New Talisman Gold Mines was up 13 per cent at 0.9 of a cent, Turners Automotive Group climbed 8.3 per cent to $2.60, and Blackwell Global Holdings was unchanged at 0.5 of a cent.