B+L research also showed a product's country or place of origin was a major factor in purchasing decisions by consumers, retailers and the food service sector.
New Zealand's competitors were investing significantly in differentiating themselves and winning.
Australia invested about $68million a year in marketing its red meat based on the True Aussie brand and Ireland invested in its sustainability programme Origin Green.
"It is critical New Zealand moves now to safeguard and enhance our position as a premium producer."
B+L chairman Andrew Morrison said research showed consumers would pay a premium for naturally raised, grass-fed hormone-free and antibiotic-free red meat.