But the closure would not stop the damage, he said.
''They keep coming and the road's not closed all the way and they get up to where it is closed and they can't go any further and then go off-course and decide to make a mess on the station.
''It's just very, very frustrating.''
Poachers also used the road and Mr Middlemass said on one occasion he caught a group on his property rustling cattle in the dark.
He wanted more monitoring of the road by police and wanted the council to extend the closure further along the road.
Before she retired last week, Senior Constable Helen Fincham-Putter, of Middlemarch, said police were aware of the issues on the road but could only react when something was reported to them.
It was up to the council to manage the road, but its isolation made it difficult, she said.
Council transport delivery manager Josh von Pein said the issues highlighted by Mr Middlemass had been raised by the Strath Taieri Community Board, which has also asked the council to extend the closure closer to Middlemarch.
The council would consult the community about options for next winter and put up extra signs if needed, Mr von Pein said.
The closure of the road was timed to fit between the annual Brass Monkey rally in Oturehua and the start of the fishing season, so it was unlikely to start earlier in the year, he said.
tim.miller@odt.co.nz