After they left the area, the police officer discovered fresh tyre tracks leading to a beach access track and discovered two wet sacks and a backpack filled with live paua.
"The paua appeared recently taken due to them being alive, wet, active and free from sand," according to the summary of facts.
The access point to the paua had been closely watched by the officer for more than half-an-hour and Kaka's vehicle was the only one he'd seen passing through the area.
The sacks contained a total 485 paua, with 483 of them under the legal minimum length.
Kaka later told police that he didn't see the approaching police vehicle and said he'd headed back to the beach because he'd forgotten some of his diving equipment.
He admitted taking the kina, but denied any knowledge when it came to the three bags of paua.
When it was put to Tohini about dumping the paua back on the beach, he said "it could have happened" and that "he may have witnessed it".
He also denied taking any seafood and then claimed he had no knowledge about the three bags of paua.
Both men were sentenced to 300 hours of community work.