Ms Bonham said she questioned whether it met a community need, as crime was low, and Mr Armstrong said ratepayers in his hometown of Becks would see no benefit.
Acting chairman Barrie Wills and VCB members Brian Fitzgerald, Russell Garbutt and Claire Goudie voted for the motion.
Sharleen Stirling-Lindsay and Malcolm Topliss were absent.
Dr Wills said ''we need to give them a chance''.
Russell Garbutt said the funding needed to be confined within the area.
''If we understood that the operation was only going to be within Vincent and confined to that, it might be OK to give them a certain amount of money.''
The patrol received $18,000 from the Central Lakes Trust's June funding round to help buy a vehicle.
Patrol chairwoman Wendy Rameka, who did not attend the meeting, said after the meeting she had not heard the funding decision and would not be in a position to comment until this week.