The local team pulled off an ambitious crayfish entre which scored plaudits from the judges, but it was the main and dessert that sealed their fate.
Kelly and Megan said that they were 'pretty devastated' about being eliminated, as they had high standards and were disappointed that they had not met them.
The elimination was not the only blow to be delivered; the episode also saw the arrival of the Gatecrashers three new teams given a shot at Kitchen HQ glory.
My Kitchen Rules was filmed throughout New Zealand, but the sisters were in the dark as to what the show would look like once it was edited, or who the overall winners will be.
"There were moments where we were relaxed, and moments which were incredibly intense and fast paced - it was fun," Megan, 28, said in an interview with Hawke's Bay Today last month.
Being sisters was a positive for the duo, who worked well together, though their personal cooking styles were varied.
My Kitchen Rules airs three times a week from 7.30pm on Sunday, Tuesday and Wednesday, TV ONE